Dysfunctional' mental health system needs boost in wake of pandemic: experts

Experts are warning the current mental health system is ill-equipped to respond to a forecast 30 per cent spike in mental illness in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic.

Dana McCauley

Dysfunctional' mental health system needs boost in wake of pandemic: experts

August 31, 2020
Experts are warning the current mental health system is ill-equipped to respond to a forecast 30 per cent spike in mental illness in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic.
Read Transcript

Experts are warning the current mental health system is ill-equipped to respond to a forecast 30 per cent spike in mental illness in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic, calling for a boost to services, similar to the response provided for COVID-19 patients.

Psychiatrist Ian Hickie, co-director of the University of Sydney's Brain and Mind Centre, said the "dysfunctional" public mental health system, in which patients cycle in and out of emergency rooms, was not equipped to respond to the crisis.

Former Australian of the Year and psychiatrist Patrick McGorry said there was "no shortage of solutions" to the crisis if decision-makers were willing to treat mental health with the same seriousness as the physical health challenge of the coronavirus, which sparked more than $2.4 billion in federal funding.

"What we're asking for is the same sort of response and they did for COVID-19, in other words, beefing up the health system to deal with it - the equivalent of ventilators and [intensive care unit] beds, but in much more community-based responses," he said.

The Morrison government this week appointed psychiatrist Ruth Vine to the Australian Health Protection Principal Committee in a signal it is taking seriously the mental health risks of the pandemic, which experts warn could result in a 25 per cent increase in suicides.

As national cabinet deliberates its coronavirus mental health recovery plan - to be unveiled on Friday - modelling by Professor McGorry's Orygen predicted an extra 370,000 Victorians would experience mental health disorders as a result of the pandemic in the next two years.

Professor McGorry, one of a group of experts advising the federal government, said this represented a 30 per cent increase and a similar pattern could be expected across the nation as Australians were impacted by job losses, economic uncertainty and isolation.

"There will be a very big wave of need for care ... that will be sustained for several years," he said.

He called for investment to boost an already "overwhelmed" mental health system, saying: "There is a huge sense of urgency around COVID-19; why can't we have that in mental health?"

Professor Hickie said governments should enlist the private sector to help respond to the mental health crisis and contract private hospitals to deliver services to public patients.

He pointed to the federal government's deal with private hospitals to deliver services if needed to help treat COVID-19 patients, saying: "I want to see the government do that immediately in mental health".

Suicide Prevention Australia chief executive Nieves Murray called for the creation of "safe spaces" where Australians could go for mental health support without having to attend hospital emergency rooms, and for Centrelink staff to be trained in suicide prevention.

Australian Private Hospitals Association Michael Roff said the sector was open to working with governments to help with the pandemic's mental health response, saying private hospitals had capacity to take on "an increased role".Ad

"A lot of people don't have private health insurance and can't get treatment in the public system," Mr Roff said.

He said there was "a need for public and private to work better together" but this had been hampered by "a reluctance from any of the public sector funding bodies to loosen their purse strings".

Australians with health insurance can access mental health services as in-patients in private hospitals instantly if they upgrade their cover, under rules that require funds waive the waiting period on a one-off basis for members who need treatment.

Comment has been sought from federal Health Minister Greg Hunt.

This article was originally posted on The Sydney Morning Herald here.

Licensed by Copyright Agency. You must not copy this work without permission.

Experts are warning the current mental health system is ill-equipped to respond to a forecast 30 per cent spike in mental illness in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic, calling for a boost to services, similar to the response provided for COVID-19 patients.

Psychiatrist Ian Hickie, co-director of the University of Sydney's Brain and Mind Centre, said the "dysfunctional" public mental health system, in which patients cycle in and out of emergency rooms, was not equipped to respond to the crisis.

Former Australian of the Year and psychiatrist Patrick McGorry said there was "no shortage of solutions" to the crisis if decision-makers were willing to treat mental health with the same seriousness as the physical health challenge of the coronavirus, which sparked more than $2.4 billion in federal funding.

"What we're asking for is the same sort of response and they did for COVID-19, in other words, beefing up the health system to deal with it - the equivalent of ventilators and [intensive care unit] beds, but in much more community-based responses," he said.

The Morrison government this week appointed psychiatrist Ruth Vine to the Australian Health Protection Principal Committee in a signal it is taking seriously the mental health risks of the pandemic, which experts warn could result in a 25 per cent increase in suicides.

As national cabinet deliberates its coronavirus mental health recovery plan - to be unveiled on Friday - modelling by Professor McGorry's Orygen predicted an extra 370,000 Victorians would experience mental health disorders as a result of the pandemic in the next two years.

Professor McGorry, one of a group of experts advising the federal government, said this represented a 30 per cent increase and a similar pattern could be expected across the nation as Australians were impacted by job losses, economic uncertainty and isolation.

"There will be a very big wave of need for care ... that will be sustained for several years," he said.

He called for investment to boost an already "overwhelmed" mental health system, saying: "There is a huge sense of urgency around COVID-19; why can't we have that in mental health?"

Professor Hickie said governments should enlist the private sector to help respond to the mental health crisis and contract private hospitals to deliver services to public patients.

He pointed to the federal government's deal with private hospitals to deliver services if needed to help treat COVID-19 patients, saying: "I want to see the government do that immediately in mental health".

Suicide Prevention Australia chief executive Nieves Murray called for the creation of "safe spaces" where Australians could go for mental health support without having to attend hospital emergency rooms, and for Centrelink staff to be trained in suicide prevention.

Australian Private Hospitals Association Michael Roff said the sector was open to working with governments to help with the pandemic's mental health response, saying private hospitals had capacity to take on "an increased role".Ad

"A lot of people don't have private health insurance and can't get treatment in the public system," Mr Roff said.

He said there was "a need for public and private to work better together" but this had been hampered by "a reluctance from any of the public sector funding bodies to loosen their purse strings".

Australians with health insurance can access mental health services as in-patients in private hospitals instantly if they upgrade their cover, under rules that require funds waive the waiting period on a one-off basis for members who need treatment.

Comment has been sought from federal Health Minister Greg Hunt.

This article was originally posted on The Sydney Morning Herald here.

Licensed by Copyright Agency. You must not copy this work without permission.

Disclaimer: This material has been prepared by Sydney Morning Herald, published on Aug 31, 2020. HM1 is not responsible for the content of linked websites or content prepared by third party. The inclusion of these links and third-party content does not in any way imply any form of endorsement by HM1 of the products or services provided by persons or organisations who are responsible for the linked websites and third-party content. This information is for general information only and does not consider the objectives, financial situation or needs of any person. Before making an investment decision, you should read the relevant disclosure document (if appropriate) and seek professional advice to determine whether the investment and information is suitable for you.

facebook
linkedin
All
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
December 5, 2023

Prof Daniel MacArthur | Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference

At this year's Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference, we heard from Prof Daniel MacArthur, the Director of the Centre for Population Genomics.

Read More
December 5, 2023

Prof Michelle Simmons AO | Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference

At this year's Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference, we heard from Prof Michelle Simmons, the CEO and Founder of Silicon Quantum Computing.

Read More
December 5, 2023

Prof Misty Jenkins AO | Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference

At this year's Sohn Hearts & Minds Conference, we heard from Prof Misty Jenkins. Misty is a NHMRC fellow and laboratory head of the Immunology Division at the Walter and Eliza Hall Institute.

Read More
December 4, 2023

Is dementia truly preventable?

In this NeuRA Talk, Professor Kaarin Anstey, Dr Nikki-Anne Wilson and Dr Bill Brooks are joined by Executive Director of Professional Services, Carole Renouf to answer the question: Is dementia truly preventable?

Read More
November 10, 2023

Big thinkers in hunt for brain cancer cure

“Brain cancer is rare, but for people who do get it the prognosis is not good,” Assistant Professor Jenkins tells The Australian.

Read More
November 6, 2023

Genomic medicine the future of health?

DNA sequences may well hold the secrets to better health. Profound changes in the practice of medicine are underway, being driven by rapid developments in several fields, particularly in genomics.

Read More
October 3, 2023

WA scientists win Hearts and Minds

We’re excited to announce that we have made our first donation to a beneficiary in Western Australia, Harry Perkins Institute of Medical Research.

Read More
Left to right: Mike Lawrence, Nicholas Kirk and Mai MargettsLeft to right: Mike Lawrence, Nicholas Kirk and Mai MargettsLeft to right: Mike Lawrence, Nicholas Kirk and Mai MargettsLeft to right: Mike Lawrence, Nicholas Kirk and Mai Margetts
July 14, 2023

Could insulin come in a pill? How a molecule that mimics insulin may advance diabetes research

WEHI researchers have answered a 100-year-old question in diabetes research: can a molecule different to insulin have the same effect?

Read More
May 8, 2023

The Florey. Where remarkable minds advance brain research.

The Florey is the home of neuroscience and mental health research, advancing knowledge of the brain to improve health outcomes for us all. Learn more about their organisation here.

Read More
May 5, 2023

Medicare Heart Health Check Saved

The Victor Chang Cardiac Research Institute says that the Federal Government's decision to extend Medicare-funded Heart Health Checks will save lives.

Read More
Merilyn Oakes and Professor Michael Feneley. Picture: John FederMerilyn Oakes and Professor Michael Feneley. Picture: John FederMerilyn Oakes and Professor Michael Feneley. Picture: John FederMerilyn Oakes and Professor Michael Feneley. Picture: John Feder
April 20, 2023

Artificial intelligence gives new hope for sufferers of severe heart problem

New AI software can improve the diagnosis of severe aortic stenosis by 72% and could potentially change the lives of about 50,000 Australians with the life-threatening condition.

Read More
April 20, 2023

Innovation Centre's key role in delivering new stroke treatments

The Innovation Centre at the Victor Chang Cardiac Research Institute has been very useful for Dr Kirsten Coupland from the University of Newcastle to help her shed light on the inner workings of the brain.

Read More
April 13, 2023

Saving Hearts to Save Lives

Professor Peter Macdonald from the Victor Chang Cardiac Research Institute opens up about his career as a cardiologist and scientist, the groundbreaking 'Heart in a Box', and the potential of deadly spider venom.

Read More
March 7, 2023

Case Study Highlight: The Baker Heart & Diabetes Institute

Working closely with Indigenous communities, The Baker Heart and Diabetes Institute is working to help tackle heart disease and diabetes in remote communities of Central Australia.

Read More
February 21, 2023

A Heart in a Box: The Gift of Life

A “heart in a box”. It sounds like an ad for Valentine’s Day chocolates. But this box contains an actual human heart which is pumping outside its original body, enabling the gift of life from one person to another.

Read More